Is the “bounce-back” in orthopedic surgery volumes sustainable as COVID cases surge?
Canaccord Genuity’s latest survey of orthopedic surgeons shows a “sharp bounce-back” in orthopedic surgery volumes, but the survey also raises concerns about sustainability, as COVID-19 rages on.
Industry stakeholders continue to pay close attention to procedure volumes — particularly orthopedic surgery — as COVID-19 continues to rage in many parts of the United States.
A recent MD+DI interview with a Renton, WA-based orthopedic surgeon and an industry executive provided some important insights regarding the challenges surgeons have faced since COVID-19, and the ways digital technology has helped to offset some of those challenges. Now, a survey from Canaccord Genuity’s Kyle Rose provides additional insights regarding current orthopedic surgery volumes and sustainability concerns.
Rose compared the recent survey results to that of similar orthopedic surgery surveys the firm conducted in March, April, and May. The survey also comes on the heels of Texas Governor Greg Abbott signing an executive order in late June to pause elective surgery as the state became a hot spot for COVID-19 cases.
“In sum, while we saw a sharp bounce-back in volumes to end the Q2, this survey raises more questions around the sustainability of that rebound continuing month-over-month in the second half of the year, particularly around rising case volumes as well as catch-up demand vs. new patient flow,” Rose said in his latest report on the issue.
According to Rose, 94% of the 50 orthopedic surgeons who responded to the firm’s latest survey said they are seeing existing and new patients in-person, up from 86% in May, and just 28% and 26% in April and March. Similarly, 70% of respondents said they are performing elective orthopedic surgeries, up from 58%, 2%, and 0% in May, April, and March, respectively.
Nonetheless, the survey also suggests little improvement in the declines in year-over-year procedure volumes as responses indicated a 43% drop in June, which was only slightly better than Canaccord’s previous surveys on the issue. The chart below illustrates year-over-year expectations for orthopedic surgery volumes in the fourth quarter.Courtesy of Canaccord Genuity
Surgeons also appear less optimistic about orthopedic surgery volumes returning to normal by the end of 2020. Rose said the percent of respondents expecting normalization in the third quarter dropped to 8% (from 18% in May, and 32% in April), and the percent expecting normalization in the fourth quarter dropped to 18% (from 27% in May, and 46% in April). Further cementing this conclusion is the fact that the percent of respondents expecting normalization in the second half of 2021 actually increased to 28% (from 14% in May, and 0% in April).
“The muted change in volume expectations despite the improvement in the percentage of physicians returning to clinic is potentially related to increased concerns about rising case volumes,” Rose said. He added that 82% of respondents expect a second wave of COVID-19 cases to impact their practice in the second half of this year.
Also, the majority of respondents’ existing orthopedic surgery cases are patients whose surgeries were previously deferred, rather than new patients, Rose said.
The survey also brings additional bad news for medical device manufacturers in the orthopedic space. Rose said that physician willingness to try new technologies, orthopedic surgery techniques that require training, and participate in clinical trials appears to have “meaningfully worsened” for the second straight month.